Manufacturing in China, main challenges and practical tips for SMEs Part 2
By Milad Nouri
Find the right manufacturer, perform a network-based sourcing
The starting point of each manufacturing project is to find the right factory. This part of the project is the most important one because it will affect the following stage of the process. The choice of the manufacturer highly depends on the type of product and the size of your business.
For instance, if your orders, in terms of quantity, do not fits the production capacity of the factory you would have problematic situations. If your quantity is much less than their usual orders, you may have commitment problem to your project. If your quantity is much more than their maximum production capacity you will have production delay problems.
Keep in mind that bigger factories do not always mean better quality. Very often smaller factories will be more committed to your project therefore they will be more willing to change and improve their production process to match your requirements.
For products with high intellectual property the choice of the factory is even more difficult, because in China the protection of intellectual property is still not well developed. For these type of products it would be more suitable to find manufacturers with no or few business relationship with your market. This could decrease the risk of possible copy of your intellectual property by your local competitors.
Finally, to accelerate your manufacturer research and to have an effective cooperation with the manufacturer, a networked-based sourcing could be performed. That is to say that you should look first, in your business network (other suppliers, partners, suppliers of your partners etc…) to try to find a suitable manufacturer. In China it often happens that you could perform better and faster using your “guanxi” (network in Chinese). This is also applicable to your sourcing, because in manufacturing projects the development part of the product could take time and requires the commitment of your manufacturer. For this matter you have to establish a mutual trust which is enabled though your network.
Audit and visit of the manufacturer
After finding the manufacturer, an audit of the factory should be performed whether by you or by a consulting company based in China. The audit has to cover the control of the factory facilities, management team, production process and working conditions. In addition, the certificates of the factory such as CE, Rohs or other standards related to your country have to be controlled to ensure that the factory has the required quality level.
However, having the certificates do not always mean good quality in mass production. Because to acquire these certificates factories make specific samples following the specifications and the factory can even change and improve the product during the certificate application. So these certificates mean that the factory is able to match the quality requirements however in mass production a quality management plan has to be defined to ensure that the factory will actually follow the specifications.
Sign a contract before the production
Since “time to market” is always very important for manufacturing projects, the contract establishment stage is often forgotten or postponed because it takes time (negotiations) and it also can be costly because it requires sometimes external resources (lawyers, experts…) to define a correct contract covering all the possible conflict situations.
In case that you do not have enough time or the budget to establish a contract conformed with international business laws, you can however write a purchase contract covering the following points:
* the manufacturing procedure
* delivery time (for samples and orders)
* exclusivity of the product and the territory (to protect your intellectual property)
* quality control process and acceptance quality level of the production
* penalties in case of late delivery or quality problems
This procedure is essential to avoid conflicts during the production and after delivery. The contract allows to write down all the aspects of the manufacturing project that even you might forget in the future and the signing of the contract improve the mutual trust.
Request and analyze samples
Before starting the production, you should request samples of your product. The sample analysis could be done by yourself or a specialized company. For the sample confirmation you have to set a high quality level because in mass production the quality level of the product might decrease.
Take the time to confirm the sample, because after sample confirmation and production start, it is not suitable to change the specifications of the product. This might cost you time, money and you could loose your credibility toward the manufacturer and it could harm the mutual trust.
Close control of the production
Once the production starts, you have to establish a strong production monitoring. First of all, the production planning should be required from the factory. Many manufacturers do not have a production management system therefore the production is not well planed. Even if the factory do not follow every day the planning, this will give them the deadlines of the production and will give them a visibility of the delivery time.
During the production you have to establish a quality control process. You can whether perform the quality inspections with your company staff or quality control company based in China. It is important to have quality inspections at the beginning of the production to detect possible defects earlier and perform the necessary changes. A pre-shipment inspection is also highly recommended to control the quality of the production to ensure that it matches the requirements. But do not wait the end of the production to worry about the quality because the quality control process should start from the very beginning of the production.
Milad Nouri, Managing Director of China Consultants Int’l Ltd.
This is the second part of “Manufacturing in China, main challenges and practical tips for SMEs” Here you can find part one.















December 18th, 2008 at 2:28 am
Milad
Very sound advise for those already sourcing and those thinking about it. We are from a similar line of work it appears, I own a company in Qingdao (www.qsq101.cn) and we assist overseas companies qualify their suppliers. I would be interested in discussing potential ways we could work together.
December 18th, 2008 at 9:39 am
There are good observations but also a lot of imprecision in this article. And I don’t agree on several points.
First, it’s easy to find suppliers (for most product categories) that make specific goods, using online platforms such as Alibaba or Global Sources. And from there it’s possible to get down to a short list and compare samples and prices. It’s much better than using connections—your contacts will introduce their friends (not the best suppliers) and might get 5% or 10% on your back.
Second, in China certificates cannot be trusted. It is the importer’s responsibility to check whether production samples (randomly picked by a representative of the buyer) pass the required tests in independent labs.
Third, the part about contracts and P/Os is confusing. For large projects you must absolutely have a contract, and you can start by reading this article: http://www.jongonews.com/articles/07/0517/15630/MTU2MzA1xfVv5Fd.html. For smaller projects, you can live without but you have to know the risks are high.
December 21st, 2008 at 6:22 pm
Good post, Milad.
I would just add that when qualifying a new supplier you should always offer to pay them to fabricate samples for you. If you offer to pay for samples and the supplier tells you they will make them for free, then that’s great. But there’s no reason for a buyer to expect or demand a supplier fabricate samples for free. They are suppliers, not equity investors in your business. What kind of message does it send to a supplier if a buyer is too cheap to offer to spend a few hundred bucks to cover setup, tooling and materials costs?
I know many readers and sourcing professionals will disagree with me on this point. The argument goes something like this: the supplier should “earn” my business. Maybe, but so many buyers have made so many suppliers jump through so many hoops, without issuing them the purchase order, that buyers who offer to pay for samples are immediately held in higher regard by suppliers. This is a good way to start a relationship. Don’t nickel-and-dime your suppliers, treat them with respect, let them cover their costs in the sampling and earn a reasonable profit in production and you will gain leverage you can use when you really need it.
Besides, if the only way you can stay in business is by squeezing your suppliers’ profits out of existence, then you’re in big trouble.
Also, Milad is right that you should look *first* within your own network to find a supplier. Renaud seems to have missed that point. If none of the suppliers with whom you have an existing relationship is qualified for the job, THEN you can go to Alibaba and Global Sources and start the long and laborious process of elimination.
December 26th, 2008 at 4:32 pm
First of all thank you for your comments. I would like to reply to some of the comments from Renaud.
Firstly about the online platforms for finding suppliers. For instance in alibaba.com there are so many users that are not even companies and most of those real companies claim to be MANUFACTURERS but they are actually trading companies. Since a good sourcing is to find manufacturers in order to decrease the number of middle companies so to get better prices. For this reason you should not only count on the online platforms because you could loose time and you may not find reliable suppliers. I do not say that you should not use them at all, there are also many reliable suppliers on these platforms, but to be efficient you could use your professional network first.
Concerning the contacts, I was referring to small and medium size manufacturing projects. In this case the contact is more to precise all the points of the project such as specifications, quality requirements, quality control process, delivery time, penalties… For sure you can live without a contact or agreement but as Renaud said there are risks and to avoid them you might spend a while to establish the contract and negotiate the terms with the manufacturer.
January 31st, 2009 at 5:35 am
Hello Milad: a great post, and very usefull information.
Starting with asking for samples and visiting is a must do when setting up a relationship with a manufacturer.
we found out, after years of sourcing, that making prototypes, samples, and small quantities is not Chinese manufacturers core competence, even the smaller factories tend to think “big” So together with a Chinese partner ( a small toolshop) we set up a special service for that. Now we making softgood samples, working samples with pcb’s etc as our special service.